Valuation of Patent: A Classification of Methodologies

Authors

  • Arundhati Banerjee
  • Rajdeep Bakshi
  • Manas Kumar Sanyal

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.33516/rb.v42i4.158-174p

Keywords:

Intellectual Property, Patents, Patent Valuation.

Abstract

In the modern days business is centred on technological development, with patents recognised as valuable assets. These are transferable in nature; hence it is necessary to determine their fair market price, thus valuation. Worldwide several methods exist for determination of financial worth of patents. Aer a review of relevant literature like serious books, journals, newspaper articles, whitepapers, and websites, it has been found that there are plenty of methods of patent valuation. These methods are either outcome of academic research or they are proprietary assets of specialist firms involved in patent valuation. Some of these models are adopted for valuation, while others remain stand-alone. The existence of such large number of methods is like a jungle, where the practitioners and academic researchers find themselves lost. In this paper an attempt has been made to map this jungle, through presenting a classification of the existing methods. The review of a large number of relevant documents given confidence, that the main approaches have been captured. The existing methods are classified into two broad groups' viz. praxis models and academic models, indicating their advantages and disadvantages.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Published

2017-01-01

How to Cite

Banerjee, A., Bakshi, R., & Sanyal, M. K. (2017). Valuation of Patent: A Classification of Methodologies. Research Bulletin, 42(4), 158–174. https://doi.org/10.33516/rb.v42i4.158-174p

Issue

Section

Articles

References

Anson, W. (2015) Alternate Approach to Valuation of Intellectual Property, Available at: www.ipwatchdog. com/2015/02/11/alternate-approach-to-the -valuationofintellectual-property/id, Accessed on: 24th Nov. 2016

American Institute of CPA: Practical Applications of Patent Valuation Approaches and Methods : Available at: www.willamette.com/pubs/.../reilly_patent_ valuation_methods_aicpa_110711.pdf Accessed on: 30th June 2015

Ahya, C. (2005) Intellectual Property Valuation: A Premier for Identifying and Determining Value, American Bar Association, pp 35

Bloom, N and Van, R. (2002) Patent Real Options and Firms Performance, The Economic Journal, Vol. 112, No. 478, pp C97-C116

Bodie, Z., Merton, R.C. and Cleeton, D. L. (2008) Financial Economics, Pearson Education India, New Delhi, pp 109

Bulakowski, A.J. (2014) Decoding Patent Valuation, Intellectual Property Magazine, September, Available at:www.intellectualpropertymagazine.com, Accessed on: 4th Nov. 2016

Chiu, Y.J. and Chen, Y.W. (2007) Using APH in Patent Valuation, Mathematical and Computer Modeling, Vol. 46, No. 07, pp 1054-1062

Cockburn, I. M. and Griliches, Z. (1987) Industry Effects and Appropriatability Measures in the Stock Market Valuation of R&D and Patents, Available at: www.nber.org/papers/w2465, Accessed on 2nd Dec. 2016

Collan, M. and Heikkila, M. (2011) Enhancing Patent Valuation with the Pay Off Method, Journal of Intellectual Property Rights, Vol. 16, No. 05, pp 377-384

Cortada, J. W. (1998) Rise Of The Knowledge Worker, Resources of the Knowledge Based Economy, Vol. 08, Knowledge Reader Series, Butterworth Heinemamm, pp 141

Drews, D. (2001) The Cost Approach to IP Valuation: Its Uses and Limitations, IP Metrices Intellectual Property Valuation Available at: http://ipmetrices.net/Cost%20 Approach.pdf, Accessed on: 25th Nov. 2016

Munari, F. and Oriani, R, (2011) Economic Valuation Of Patents: Methods And Applications, New Horizons in Intellectual Property Series, Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd., Cheltenham Glos UK

Frietsch, R., Neuhäusler, P., Jung., T. and Looy, B.V (2014), Patent Indicators For Macroeconomic Growth—The Value Of Patents Estimated By Export Volume, Technovation, Vol. 34, pp. 546–558

Goldenberg, D. H. and Linton, J. D, (2012) The Patent Paradox – New Insights Through Decision Support Using Compound Options, Technological Forecasting & Social Change, Vol. 79, pp 180-185

Goldscheider, R., Jarosz, J. and Mulhern, R. (2002) Use Of The 25 Per Cent Rule In Valuing IP, Ies Nouvelles, Vol. 37, No. 04, pp 123-133

Greenhalgh, C.and ,Rogers, .M (2006), The Value Of Innovation: The Interaction Of Competition, R&D and IP, Research Policy, Vol. 35, pp 562-580

Grimaldi, M, Livio, Giovanni M. D and Rog, F. (2015). The Patent Portfolio Value Analysis: A New Framework To Leverage Patent Information For Strategic Technology Planning, Technological Forecasting & Social Change, Vol. 94, pp 286-302

Hagelin, .T. (2002) A New Method to Value Intellectual Property, Aâ€AIPLA QJ, Vol. 30. pp 353

Hall, B.H. and Macgarvie, M. ( 2010), The Private Value Of Soware Patents, Research Policy, Vol. 39, pp 994–1009

Han, E. J. and Sohn., S.Y. (2015), Patent Valuation Based On Text Mining And Survival Analysis, Journal Of Technology Transfer, Vol. 40, pp 821-839

ICAI,(2007) A Handbook On Valuation Of Intellectual Property In Emerging Countries Like India-Accounting To Take A Lead Role, Commiee On Trade Laws and WTO, New Delhi

Jarosz, J., Heider, R., Bazelon, C., Bieri, C., and Hess, P. (2010) Patent Auctions: How Far Have we Come?, Organization, Vol. 21, pp 23

Jun, S., Park, S. and Jang, .D.(2015), A Technology Valuation Model Using Quantitative Patent Analysis: A Case Study Of Technology Transfer In Big Data Marketing, Emerging Markets Finance and Trade, Vol. 51, pp 963–974

Kelly, A. (2011) Practicing in the Patent Market Place, The University of Chicago Law Review, Vol. 78, No. 01, pp 115 - 137

aLee, J.H., Youngyoung, I, Lee, II. H. and Lee, J.W. (2016) Valuation Using Royalty Data in the Life Science AreaFocused on Anticancer and Cardiovascular Therapies, Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market and Complexity, Vol. 02, No 01

bLee, H.J., Su, K.B. Lee, J.W., Youngyoung, I.N, Kwon, T. and Lee, W. (2016) Valuation Methods by Regression Analysis on Real Royalty Related Data by using multiple input descriptors in Royalty Negotiation in Life Science Area Focused on Anti-Cancer Therapies, Journal of Open Innovation: Technology, Market and Complexity, Vol. 02, No 21

Leone, M. I, and Orianim, R, The Option Value Of Patent Licenses , Available at: www.epip.eu/.../LEONE_ ORIANI_theoptionvalueofpatentlicenses, Accessed on: 17th Apr. 2012

Meeks, M.T. and Eldering, C.A. (2010), Patent Valuation:Aren’t We Forgetting Something? Making The Case For Claims Analysis In Patent Valuation By Proposing A Patent Valuation Method And A Patent-Specific Discount Rate Using The CAPM, Northwestern Journal of Technology and Intellectual Property, Vol. 09, No.03, pp 194-240

Meng, R (2008) Patent Race in a Real Option Seing: Investment Strategy, Valuation, CAPM Beta, and return Volatility, Journal of Economics Dynamics and Control, Vol. 32, No. 10, pp 3192-3217

Flammer, R. (2014) Patent Valuation And Commercialization: Making The Most Of Patents For Business: Closing Remarks Available at: https://www.Obi.Gr/OBI/Portals/0/Imagesandfiles/.../Day1_04_ Reuven_Mouallem.pdf, Accessed on: 9th Apr. 2015

Park, Y. and Park, G.(2004), A New Method For Technology Valuation In Monetary Value: Procedure And Application, Technovation, Vol. 24, pp 387–394

Razgaitis, R., Krattiger, A., Mahoney, R.T., Nelsen, L, Thomson, J.A., Bennett, A.B.,….And Kowalski, S.P. (2007), Pricing The Intellectual Property of Early-Stage Technologies: A Primer Of Basic Valuation Tools And Considerations, Intellectual Property in Health and Agricultural Innovation: a Handbook of Best Practices, Vol. 01 and 02, pp 813-860 Available at: http://www.iphandbook.org/handbook/ch09/p03/

Reitzig, M. (2000) Methods For Patent Portfolio Valuations, Available at: www.oecd.org/sti/scitech/ 35428864.pdf, Accessed on:1st May 2015

Russel, M. (2016), The Valuation of Pharmaceutical Intangibles, Journal Of Intellectual Capital, Vol. 17, No.03, pp 484-506

Sebastian, H., Legler, .E. and Lichtenthaler, U., (2010) Determinants of Patent Value: Insights From A Simulation Analysis, Technological Forecasting and Social Change, Vol. 77, pp 01-19

Sereno, .L, (2010) Real Options Valuation of Pharmaceutical Patents. A Case Study, Available at: SSRN 1547185, Accessed on: 05th Oct. 2012

Sohn, S. Y., Lee, W. S.and Ju, Y. H, (2013), Valuing Academic Patents and Intellectual Properties: Different Perspectives Of Willingness To Pay And Sell, Technovation, Vol. 33, pp 13-24

Triest, S, and Vis,.W, (2007), Valuing Patents on Cost-Reducing Technology: A Case Study, Production Economics, Vol. 105, pp 282-292

Wang B, Hsieh, C-H (2015) Measuring The Value Of Patents With Fuzzy Multiple Criteria Decision Making, Technological Forecasting and Social Change, Vol. 92, pp 263-275

Wartburg, I, and Teichert, T, (2008) Valuing Patents and Licenses from a Business Strategy Perspective Extending Valuation Considerations Using the Case of Nanotechnology, World Patent Information, Vol. 30, pp 106–114